Kinect Sports: Season Two arrived in October 2011 with six sports, a heavier reliance on voice than its predecessor, and a sensor that had already sold millions. Rare and BigPark built it for the Xbox 360, Microsoft Studios published it, and it still needs the Kinect camera to do anything at all.
That requirement is the whole story. Nothing here works with a standard controller.
Trailer, via IGN.
Golf, Darts, Baseball, Skiing, Tennis, Football
Kinect Sports: Season Two offers golf, darts, baseball, skiing, tennis and American football, all reachable from the main menu. Each can be played solo or with others, including split screen.
You control everything with gestures and speech. No physical controller is involved. You swing your arms as if holding a golf club. You kick to score a field goal in American football. The game asks you to mimic the real sport without the real equipment.
That mimicry is the pitch and the problem. When it reads your motion cleanly, the illusion holds. When it does not, there is nothing to fall back on, because there is no controller in your hands.
Over 300 Voice Commands
Season Two leans on speech recognition far more than the 2010 original did. The game ships with over 300 voice commands.
Golf is the clearest example. You can switch clubs by saying so, without walking back to a menu. That sounds like a small thing. It is not. Menus are where motion games go to die, and cutting one out keeps you standing in the swing.
Rare demonstrated the American football mode with two players at once, one on quarterback and one on receiver. The quarterback mimes a throw. The receiver mimics the catch. At E3, the team also showed a field goal trial where a player attempts the kick with a full kicking motion.
What Rare and BigPark Kept and Added
The sequel’s relationship to the first Kinect Sports is worth laying out plainly, because the bundle muddies it.
| Feature | Kinect Sports (2010) | Kinect Sports: Season Two (2011) |
|---|---|---|
| Developer | Rare | Rare and BigPark |
| Publisher | Microsoft Studios | Microsoft Studios |
| Platform | Xbox 360 | Xbox 360 |
| Kinect sensor required | Yes | Yes |
| Voice command volume | Baseline | Over 300 commands |
| Sports added later | — | Basketball, golf, skiing |
On 18 September 2012, both games shipped together as the Kinect Sports Ultimate Collection, with bonus content and three extra sports folded into Season Two: basketball, golf and skiing. That bundle is the version most people who came late actually met.
A Full Swing Beats a Dart Throw
The sports that reward a big, readable body movement hold up best. A golf swing is a full arc. A field goal kick is a leg. A baseball pitch is an arm. The sensor has something large and obvious to track.
Darts is the opposite case. It is a game of small, precise hand movement, and precision is exactly what full-body tracking is worst at. Skiing sits somewhere in between, asking for posture and balance rather than a single sharp motion.
The voice layer helps most where the motion layer is weakest. Saying a club name beats miming a club change. Speech recognition is doing the job a button used to do, and it does it without breaking your stance.
Here is the ranking of the six events by how well the Kinect premise serves them:
- Golf — a full swing arc plus voice club changes, the best marriage of motion and speech.
- American football — throwing and kicking are large, legible motions, and two-player quarterback-to-receiver play is the sharpest demo Rare showed.
- Baseball — a pitch is a single clean arm motion the sensor can read.
- Tennis — a swing is readable, but the back-and-forth demands reactions the camera can lag behind.
- Skiing — posture and balance work, though the motion is subtler than a swing.
- Darts — the smallest movement in the set, and the one full-body tracking handles worst.
More Sports, Same Ceiling
Season Two is a better game than Kinect Sports in the ways sequels usually are. It is broader, it talks back, and it has more to do. Six sports is a real lineup, and the split-screen and Xbox Live competition modes give it a life past the first week.
It is not a braver game. Every addition here is an extension of what the first one already did: more events, more commands, more modes. The bet on the sensor was made in 2010. Season Two just raises it.
That is a defensible move for a studio following a multi-million seller. It is also why the game never escapes the ceiling of its own hardware. The Kinect is the constraint, and no amount of new sports changes that. When the camera misses your swing, the game has no second answer.
The voice commands are the genuine step forward. Over 300 of them, used in places where a menu would otherwise interrupt play, is the kind of fix that improves everything around it. Golf without a club-switching menu is simply a better version of golf.
The E3 demonstrations told the same story. Rare put two people in a room, one throwing and one catching, and let the sensor carry the exchange. That is the pitch in miniature: not a controller replacement, a party trick with real coordination behind it.
Kinect Sports: Season Two is a solid second entry that knows exactly what it is. It is a party sports game built for a camera, and it does that job with more range and more voice than the first one managed.
The events that ask for big motions — golf, football, baseball — are where it earns its place. The ones that ask for precision, darts above all, show the ceiling clearly.
If you owned a Kinect in 2011, this was one of the better reasons to keep it plugged in. If you did not, nothing here was going to change your mind, and the Ultimate Collection bundle a year later was the smarter buy anyway.
It is not a great game. It is a good one that got the most out of a peripheral with obvious limits, and it never pretends otherwise.
7.3 of 10 (IGDB critic aggregate, 6 outlets)
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
