Clint Eastwood’s Mystic River opens in 1975 on a Charlestown, Boston street, where three boys scratch their names into wet concrete. Within minutes, two men posing as police officers take Dave Boyle into a car. He escapes four days later, after being raped. The film spends the next two hours measuring what that afternoon cost.
Trailer, via YouTube Movies.
Three Boys, One Patch of Wet Concrete
Twenty-five years on, the friends have separated into three lives. Jimmy Markum is an ex-convict who runs a neighborhood convenience store. Sean Devine is a Massachusetts State Police detective whose pregnant wife, Lauren, recently left him. Dave is a blue-collar worker still haunted by the abduction. Jimmy and Dave are bound by marriage: Dave’s wife, Celeste, and Jimmy’s second wife, Annabeth, are cousins.
Katie Markum and Brendan Harris
Jimmy’s daughter from his first marriage, Katie, plans to run away to Las Vegas with Brendan Harris, a boy from a family Jimmy despises. She has been dating him in secret. One night Dave sees Katie and her friends at a local bar. That same night she is murdered. Dave comes home bloodied and injured, saying he fought off a mugger and may have killed him.
A .38 Special and a 1984 Robbery
Sean and his partner, Whitey Powers, work the case while Jimmy runs his own investigation through neighborhood connections. A witness statement suggests Katie may have recognized her killer. The detectives learn the murder weapon, a .38 Special revolver, was also used in a 1984 liquor store robbery by “Just Ray” Harris, Brendan’s father. Harris has been missing since 1989. Brendan says his father still sends the family $500 a month and claims to know nothing about the gun. Whitey suspects Dave, whose account of his injured hand keeps changing.
Penn, Robbins, Bacon
- Sean Penn as Jimmy Markum
- Tim Robbins as Dave Boyle
- Kevin Bacon as Sean Devine
- Laurence Fishburne as Whitey Powers
- Marcia Gay Harden as Celeste Boyle
- Laura Linney as Annabeth Markum
Eastwood’s First Score
Brian Helgeland wrote the screenplay from Dennis Lehane’s 2001 novel. Eastwood directed and co-produced through Malpaso Productions, with Village Roadshow Pictures and NPV Entertainment. Mystic River premiered at Cannes on May 23, 2003, and Warner Bros. released it on October 15, 2003. It is the first film on which Eastwood is credited as composer of the score.
The Tagline Earns Its Place
“We bury our sins, we wash them clean.” The line is not decoration. Every man in Mystic River is trying to wash something, and the film refuses to let any of them finish.
What the Film Gets Right
The abduction is the whole architecture. Dave’s four days offscreen shape his marriage, his testimony and his alibi, and the film never lets the audience forget the debt. Robbins plays the damage as a man managing it, not displaying it, which is why Whitey’s suspicion lands. Penn gets the louder role and takes it.
The mystery is the weaker half. The .38 Special ties the cases together cleanly, but the solution matters less than what Jimmy does with it. Eastwood’s restraint serves the material better than any twist could.
Mystic River was nominated for six Academy Awards, including Best Picture, and won Best Actor for Penn and Best Supporting Actor for Robbins. That is the right pair of wins. The film is an actor’s picture built on a director’s patience, and its best scenes are two men in a room deciding how much to say.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
