“Truth Be Told” wants to be the definitive true-crime drama. It gets close. What it doesn’t get is pace. The show, created by Nichelle Tramble Spellman for Apple TV+, follows Poppy Parnell (Octavia Spencer) as she reopens old cases with new evidence. The premise is strong. The execution sags.
Trailer, via Apple TV.
Poppy’s Podcast
Poppy is a podcaster who made her name covering a 1999 murder case. When new evidence surfaces, she revisits the conviction of Warren Cave, the man she helped send to prison. That setup is sharp. The problem is the slow burn. Each episode drags its feet before it gets to the meat of the case.
Spencer carries the weight. She sells Poppy’s determination and her moral compass. But the show leans on flashbacks and exposition-heavy conversations that feel like padding. The pacing problem is not a small one. It runs through every season.
Season by Season
Season 1 sets up the template. Poppy digs into the Chuck Buhrman case and finds cracks in the prosecution’s story. The second season shifts to a filmmaker’s murder, requested by his wife Micah, a wellness guru whose friendship with Poppy complicates things. The third season tracks the disappearances of several young black girls in Oakland, while a mayoral candidate uses a white girl’s disappearance for his campaign.
| Season | Focus | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Chuck Buhrman murder case | Strong setup | Slow pacing |
| 2 | Filmmaker murder | Solid storytelling | Exposition heavy |
| 3 | Disappearances of young black girls | Ambitious scope | Uneven quality |
The third season tries hardest to break new ground. But the uneven quality shows. Some episodes land. Others feel like filler.
The Cast and the Music
The cast is deep. Mekhi Phifer, David Lyons, Gabrielle Union, Ron Cephas Jones and the rest bring real presence to their roles. The casting history is notable: Octavia Spencer was confirmed for the lead in June 2018, followed by Lizzy Caplan, Aaron Paul, Elizabeth Perkins and others joining in July and August of that year. Tami Roman and Moon Bloodgood joined in July 2018, with Bloodgood later dropping out of the role of Cath Min after filming the first four episodes.
The music deserves credit. John Paesano’s soundtrack was released by Lakeshore Records on the same day the show premiered. It anchors the tone without overpowering the dialogue.
What Works, What Doesn’t
The show is at its best when it focuses on the cases themselves. The moral questions around justice and truth are handled with care. But the middle stretches lose momentum. Episodes that could be tightened into hour-long installments stretch across multiple outings, diluting the tension.
The show also struggles with its own ambitions. It wants to cover institutional racism, media bias and the power of podcasts all at once. That’s a lot to hold. The result is a show that feels stretched thin rather than layered richly.
Final Word
“Truth Be Told” is a show with a great idea and a habit of losing steam. Spencer’s performance holds it together. The writing, less so. The show was canceled after three seasons, which is a shame given how much promise it showed early on.
The show is worth watching for its first season. Beyond that, the payoff thins out. The final score: 4.6 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
