“Some legends can never be tamed,” the poster for Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron promised in 2002. The movie mostly keeps that promise, and that is the problem. DreamWorks Animation built an 83-minute Western around a horse who refuses to bend, then handed him a voice that will not stop explaining how much he refuses to bend. Spirit opened in theaters on May 24, 2002, was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature, and grossed $122 million worldwide against an $80 million budget. It earns a 5.2 out of 10 here.
Trailer, via DreamWorks Spirit.
A Kiger Mustang Born in 1887
Set in the Old West in the late 19th century, the film opens in 1887 with the birth of Spirit, a Kiger mustang colt, to a herd of wild horses. He grows into a stallion and takes over the herd’s leadership. One night he follows a strange light and finds horses tied to a log, with their wranglers asleep around a campfire. The men wake. After a chase, they capture him and haul him to a US cavalry fort.
That is the engine of the whole picture: a free animal moved by force into a place built to break him. Kelly Asbury and Lorna Cook directed, John Fusco wrote the screenplay from an idea by Jeffrey Katzenberg, and Katzenberg produced with Mireille Soria. Michael Lucker shares a writing credit. The setup is lean and it works. The capture sequence is the cleanest stretch of storytelling in the film.
The Colonel Orders Spirit Broken
At the fort, the senior officer, the Colonel, orders Spirit broken. James Cromwell voices him. Spirit defies every attempt and beats up the farrier. The Colonel answers by having him tied to a post for three days without food or water, to weaken him. A Lakota man named Little Creek, voiced by Daniel Studi, is brought into the fort as a captive too. His friends toss a knife over the wall, and he uses it to cut his bonds in secret.
After the three days, Spirit is weak enough that the Colonel temporarily subdues him. The Colonel boasts that any wild horse can eventually be tamed. Spirit sees the other captive horses’ disappointment, regains his strength, and throws the Colonel off, breaking down the corral’s wall. The Colonel orders his men to kill the horse. Little Creek saves him, and the two escape, freeing the other captive horses on the way out.
Little Creek, Rain, and a Rope
Little Creek and other Lakota people lasso Spirit and take him back to their village. There, Little Creek tries to tame him with kindness and fails. So he ties the other end of Spirit’s lead rope to his pet mare, Rain, hoping she can discipline him. Spirit falls in love with Rain while staying wary of any attachment to humans. He and Little Creek gradually come to respect each other. Realizing Spirit is not meant to be domesticated, Little Creek sets him free.
The film’s best idea sits in that stretch. Spirit and the other horses communicate through non-linguistic sounds and body language, not dialogue, which sets them apart from the anthropomorphic animals of most animated features. It is a real formal choice, and it is the reason the movie looks like nothing else DreamWorks released that decade.
Matt Damon Narrates the Horse
Then Matt Damon opens his mouth. Damon voices Spirit as a narrator, and the narration is the single decision that holds Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron back from being a very good film. The horses already say everything through posture and breath. Damon’s voice arrives to translate, and the translation is always less interesting than the thing translated.
The supporting cast is solid and underused. Daniel Studi gives Little Creek a quiet steadiness. James Cromwell is exactly the right kind of stiff as the Colonel. Chopper Bernet plays Sgt. Adams, Jeff LeBeau plays Murphy, the first soldier who tries to break Spirit, and also voices a Railroad Foreman. Richard McGonagle, Matt Levin, Adam Paul, Robert Cait and Charles Napier voice the wranglers Bill, Joe, Pete, Jake and Roy. Meredith Wells voices Little Indian Girl. Zahn McClarnon, Michael Horse and Donald Fullilove also appear. Most of these men get a line or two and no arc.
Traditional Animation, Computer Animation, and Bryan Adams
DreamWorks produced the film by combining traditional animation and computer animation, and the blend holds up better than the narration does. The landscapes carry scale. The chase and escape sequences have weight and speed. The horses’ faces are expressive in ways that are close to human without tipping into cartoon.
Ranking what the film gets right and wrong:
- The wordless horse communication, which is the film’s genuine invention and its strongest asset.
- The capture and fort sequences, which build real threat without wasting a scene.
- The Rain storyline, which earns its emotional turn through action rather than speech.
- The Matt Damon narration, which undercuts all three of the above.
- The Colonel, who never becomes more than a uniform with a grudge.
That is the shape of the thing. The craft is high, the instincts are good, and one creative choice keeps stepping in front of the camera.
A Franchise That Left the Hand-Drawn Horses Behind
Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron launched a media franchise, and the franchise went a different way. A Netflix spin-off series, Spirit Riding Free, premiered on May 5, 2017, built completely with computer animation. A spin-off of the original film, Spirit Untamed, followed on June 4, 2021. Neither carries the hand-drawn-and-CG hybrid look that gives the 2002 film its texture. The property outgrew its own visual identity.
That matters when weighing the original. Spirit is not a bad movie that got lucky. It is a good movie that got overruled, and the overruling came from inside the production. Katzenberg’s idea, Fusco’s script, Asbury and Cook’s direction, and the animation team’s restraint all point one way. The narration points the other.
The 2002 release also sits at a specific moment for DreamWorks Animation, which was building a slate of features that mixed formats and tones rather than repeating a house style. Spirit fits that ambition. It just does not trust its own audience enough to let a horse be a horse for 83 minutes.
What Spirit Gets Right and What It Cannot Stop Doing
The restraint is the whole argument. An animated Western told from a stallion’s point of view, set during the American Indian Wars, with a Lakota man as the human who understands him, is a strange and admirable thing for a major studio to make in 2002. The film treats Little Creek as a person with his own reasons, not a plot device, and it treats Spirit’s refusal as a principle rather than a gag.
Then Damon explains the principle out loud, and the movie flattens. A viewer can feel the exact moment the film stops trusting its own images.
So the score is 5.2 out of 10. The animation, the chase work, the wordless horse communication and the Rain storyline are worth the time. The narration is not, and it is constant. Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron is a film about an animal that will not be tamed, narrated by a man who will not be quiet. The legend holds. The telling gets in the way.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
