Greta Evans takes a job as nanny to the Heelshires’ eight-year-old son, Brahms. The couple treat the boy as real. He is a life-sized doll, and he comes with a list of strict rules.
Trailer, via STXfilms.
A Nanny Job in a Remote English Village
Greta, an American travelling in the United Kingdom, is hired by the elderly Heelshires. They coach her on caring for Brahms and on the house, then leave on holiday.
Director William Brent Bell and writer Stacey Menear built the film around that gap — a woman caring for an object the people who hired her refuse to call an object. Lauren Cohan plays Greta. Rupert Evans plays Malcolm, the Heelshires’ grocery boy, who stops by often enough to become the movie’s second pair of eyes.
The Boy is a horror, mystery and thriller. It runs 98 minutes.
Malcolm Explains the Fire
Malcolm tells Greta the real Brahms died in a fire 20 years ago, on his eighth birthday. He also says the girl Brahms was friends with, Emily Cribbs, was found in the forest with her skull crushed, and that the Heelshires’ house burned afterward with the boy inside.
That is the film’s best material, and it arrives as talk. The Boy keeps its history in other people’s mouths.
The Rules Greta Ignores
Greta ignores the rules. She calls her sister, who warns her that Greta’s abusive ex-boyfriend Cole is trying to find her. Malcolm asks her out. While she showers for the date, her dress and jewellery vanish. She goes into the attic after a noise, gets trapped, and is knocked unconscious. She misses the date.
The film’s horror runs on small thefts and locked doors. A peanut butter and jelly sandwich appears outside her room. A child’s voice promises he will be good. Greta starts taking the rules seriously.
Every child needs to feel loved.
A Doll That Moves When No One Watches
Greta works out the mechanic: the doll only moves when she is not in the room with him. Bell stages this cleanly. The trouble is that a rule this simple cannot carry 98 minutes, and the film keeps restating it instead of testing it.
Cohan does the heavy work. Her Greta has a real reason to stay — an ex she is hiding from — and Cohan plays the obligation without sentiment. Evans is likable as Malcolm, though the script gives him little to do but deliver backstory and then get declined when he offers help.
The Heelshires Write a Goodbye Letter
The Heelshires write a goodbye letter to Brahms and drown themselves. Cole arrives without warning and demands Greta return to America with him in the morning. The film treats the parents’ suicide as a plot turn, not as the horror it is. Two people who chose a doll over their own lives is the most frightening idea in The Boy. Menear puts it in a letter and moves on.
The Cast Behind the Doll
James Russell plays Brahms Heelshire, with Jett Klyne as Child Brahms. Jim Norton and Diana Hardcastle play Mr. and Mrs. Heelshire. Ben Robson is Cole. Lily Pater is Emily Cribbs. Matthew Walker is the Taxi Driver, and Stephanie Lemelin voices Sandy.
A Sequel Arrives in 2020
The Boy opened in the United States on January 22, 2016, from STXfilms. It grossed $64 million worldwide on a $10 million budget. Reviews were mixed to negative. Brahms: The Boy II followed on February 21, 2020.
- Runtime: 98 minutes
- Release: January 22, 2016 (United States), STXfilms
- Budget: $10 million
- Worldwide gross: $64 million
- Filming began: March 10, 2015, Victoria, British Columbia
- Sequel: Brahms: The Boy II, February 21, 2020
- Score: 4.2/10
What the Doll Is Worth
The Boy is a China–United States co-production that turned a $10 million budget into $64 million, and the math explains the sequel better than anything in the story does. The premise is strong. The execution is thin.
Bell and Menear found one good image — a couple dressing a doll in a child’s clothes and writing him rules — and then spent the rest of the runtime explaining it. The attic, the sandwich, the missing dress, the voice: each beat is a separate scare rather than a step toward anything. The film never decides whether Greta believes the doll is possessed or knows she is humouring two grieving parents, and that indecision flattens Cohan’s best scenes.
The drowning is the proof. A movie that understood its own cruelty would have ended there, with the parents, not with Cole at the door. Instead The Boy reaches for a third act it has not earned and leaves its sharpest idea folded in a letter.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
