ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

The Rock Is a Good Movie With a Long Second Half

A retro review of Michael Bay's 1996 action thriller The Rock, starring Sean Connery, Nicolas Cage and Ed Harris, and what still holds up.

By mitch·8 min read
A man clings to a helicopter as it flies above the fog-covered island of Alcatraz.

The Rock opens with a man in a military uniform walking into a naval weapons depot and walking out with fifteen rockets. That is the whole engine of the movie. Michael Bay’s 1996 action thriller does not waste time on motivation before it gets to the theft, and for a while that confidence carries it.

Brigadier General Francis Hummel, played by Ed Harris, leads a rogue group of Force Recon Marines. They steal the rockets, which are loaded with VX gas, from a U.S. Navy facility. The next day they take over the former prison on Alcatraz Island and hold the tourists and guards hostage. Hummel calls the FBI and the Pentagon. He wants $100 million, paid within 72 hours, and he says the money goes to the families of the men who died under his command and were never compensated. If he does not get it, he launches the rockets at the San Francisco Bay Area.

The setup is clean. A soldier with a grievance, a fortress nobody can crack, a city in the crosshairs. The Rock knows exactly what it is doing for about an hour.

Advertisement

Trailer, via TrailerTrackerEnglish.

Sean Connery and the Man Who Broke Out

The FBI and the Department of Defense decide to retake Alcatraz from below, through the old tunnel system under the island. Navy SEALs under Commander Anderson will make the run. The Bureau needs someone who can disarm the rockets safely, so it pulls in Dr. Stanley Goodspeed, a chemical weapons specialist played by Nicolas Cage.

Goodspeed is the audience. He is a lab man, not a field man, and Cage plays him as a nervous talker who keeps working out loud while everyone else is shooting. The movie gets real mileage from the gap between his job and his situation.

The problem is the tunnels. Nobody in the room knows them. So FBI Director James Womack, played by John Spencer, has to make a call he clearly hates. He brings in John Mason.

Mason is Sean Connery. He is a former British SAS captain, MI6-trained, and the only man who has ever escaped Alcatraz. He got out after stealing a microfilm made by J. Edgar Hoover that held classified U.S. information. When he was caught, he refused to say where the microfilm was, because he figured he would be killed once he talked. So the government skipped the trial and locked him up without one.

Connery is the best thing in the movie and the movie knows it. Mason agrees to help only after he is shown a pardon that clears his record. Womack destroys it almost immediately after. That single move tells you everything about how this film sees institutions: the deal is a lie, the paper is a prop, and the only thing Mason can trust is his own read of the room.

The Car Chase and the Daughter

Mason does not wait around to be managed. He escapes, and the film spends a long stretch on a car chase through the city that turns into a rampage before Goodspeed finally catches him. He catches him at a meeting with Jade, Mason’s estranged daughter.

That is the emotional hinge of The Rock, and it is thinner than the movie wants it to be. Mason’s daughter exists to give Connery a soft scene, and the film treats her as a stop on the way to the island rather than a person. It works because Connery underplays it. It does not work because the script earned it.

At the command center, Mason negotiates his way onto the team heading to Alcatraz. This is the part where the movie stops being a heist and becomes a siege, and the two leads finally share the screen for real. Connery and Cage have a rhythm — the old pro and the lab rat, the man who has nothing left to lose and the man who has everything to get back to. Their scenes together are the reason the film has lasted.

Then the team infiltrates the prison, and Hummel’s men find out they are there. The movie never quite recovers the tension it had in the first act.

Ed Harris Plays the Only Adult in the Room

Hummel is the film’s best-written character, and Harris plays him without a single wink. He is not a lunatic. He is a man who watched his government send soldiers to die and then refuse to pay their families, and he has decided that the only language left is a gun to the head of a city.

That is a real argument, and the film is smart enough to let him make it. It is also smart enough to put Major Tom Baxter, played by David Morse, at his side as the loyal subordinate who does not flinch. The supporting cast around Hummel is deep: William Forsythe as Special Agent Ernest Paxton, Michael Biehn as Commander Charles Anderson, John C. McGinley as Marine Captain Hendrix, Gregory Sporleder as Captain Frye, Tony Todd as Captain Darrow, Bokeem Woodbine as Sergeant Crisp.

The film is dedicated to producer Don Simpson, who died five months before it came out. It was produced by Simpson and Jerry Bruckheimer and released by Buena Vista Pictures Distribution through the Hollywood Pictures label on June 7, 1996. It was written by David Weisberg, Douglas S. Cook and Mark Rosner, with later work by Jonathan Hensleigh. It runs 137 minutes.

What the Film Does With Its Money

The Rock earned over $335 million at the box office on a production budget of $75 million. That made it the fourth highest-grossing film of 1996. It got generally positive reviews and a Best Sound nomination at the 69th Academy Awards.

The money is on the screen. The Alcatraz location work is the film’s strongest visual asset, and Bay uses the real cellblocks, the real rock, the real water around it. When the movie is inside the prison, it feels like a place. When it is in the tunnels, it feels like a set.

Here is where the film’s reputation and its actual quality part ways. The Rock is remembered as a high point of 1990s action, and the Connery-Cage pairing is genuinely good. But the movie is 137 minutes long, and the last third is a series of standoffs that keep restating the same threat. The countdown clock does not build. It just sits there.

Element What The Rock Gets Right What It Gets Wrong
Casting Connery as Mason, Cage as Goodspeed, Harris as Hummel — three distinct registers that hold Jade, Mason’s daughter, is a plot device, not a character
Setting Alcatraz as a real, physical fortress with tunnels and cellblocks The tunnels become a generic dark corridor
Stakes 15 VX rockets aimed at the Bay Area, 72-hour deadline, $100 million demand The deadline stops generating tension well before it expires
Tone Hummel’s grievance is treated as a real argument The film keeps cutting away from it to shootouts

The Part That Outlived the Movie

The Rock has a second life that has nothing to do with its box office. Britain’s Secret Intelligence Service was led to believe Saddam Hussein was still producing weapons of mass destruction by a false agent who based his reports on The Rock, according to the Chilcot Inquiry. A Hollywood action film became source material for a real intelligence failure. That is a stranger legacy than any of the film’s set pieces.

The film was also remade in India in 2003 as Qayamat: City Under Threat. And at one point Arnold Schwarzenegger was set to play Goodspeed. He turned it down because he did not like the script. It is hard to imagine the movie working with him in that role. Cage’s jumpiness is what makes Goodspeed feel like a man out of his depth rather than a man who could punch his way out.

Where the Rock Sits in the Bay Canon

Ranking the film’s assets is not the same as ranking the film, but it clarifies what the movie is actually selling.

  1. Sean Connery as John Mason — the performance the entire film leans on, and the only one that survives the third act.
  2. Ed Harris as General Hummel — the villain with the strongest case, and the film’s conscience.
  3. The Alcatraz location — real cellblocks, real rock, real water, and the best thing Bay ever pointed a camera at.
  4. Nicolas Cage as Dr. Stanley Goodspeed — the audience surrogate, effective in the two-hander scenes and stranded in the shootouts.
  5. The tunnel infiltration — the premise that gets everyone underground, and the sequence that ages worst.
  6. Jade, Mason’s daughter — the emotional beat the script never earns.

What Holds Up and What Does Not

The Rock works when it is a two-hander. Mason and Goodspeed in a cell, Mason and Goodspeed in a tunnel, Mason and Goodspeed arguing about whether the mission is worth finishing. Connery gives the film its spine. Cage gives it its pulse. Harris gives it its conscience.

It fails when it forgets that and becomes a montage of men with guns running through dark spaces. The film has a great premise, a great cast and a great location, and it spends too much of its runtime on the least interesting version of all three.

The VX rockets are the clearest example. They are the reason the movie exists, and the movie treats disarming them as a technical chore rather than a source of dread. Goodspeed’s expertise should be the most frightening thing in the film. Instead it is a plot mechanism that gets him from room to room.

The Rock Is a Good Movie With a Long Second Half

The Rock is a good movie with a great first hour and a long, loud second one. The Connery-Cage pairing is the reason to watch it, and Ed Harris gives the villain a case worth hearing. But the film mistakes escalation for tension, and by the time the countdown matters, the audience has already stopped counting.

It is a 1996 action film that helped define what a 1996 action film looked like, and it deserves credit for that. It does not deserve credit for its length, its treatment of its one female character, or its refusal to trust its own best idea.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Film reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.