The Sims 2: Castaway washed up on the Wii and PlayStation 2 in 2007 with a simple promise: take a crew of ordinary people, drop them on a deserted tropical island, and make them survive. The Sims Division developed it. Electronic Arts published it. It was the third console spin-off of The Sims 2, and it was the last game in the series to ship for the PlayStation 2.
That last detail matters more than it looks. Castaway arrived at the end of a console generation and the end of a run. It also arrived with a good idea.
Trailer, via YoshiMints.
Shipwreck Island Is Where You Learn the Rules
The game opens on a boat. You create a crew of one to six Sims first, choosing from a set of working lives: Auto Mechanic, Chef, Doctor, Musician, Teacher, Executive, or Park Ranger. Each one brings a different humor and quirkiness to the crew. Then a slide-show plays, built from mobile phone pictures of the trip, and the storm that wrecks the ship shows up in the same set of images.
Your starting Sim wakes on First Beach on Shipwreck Island. Books are waiting there, and the books lay out the goals you have to follow to survive and to escape. This is the game teaching you its structure without a tutorial voice barking in your ear.
Shortly after you explore Shipwreck Island, you find a second island. Airplane Island is considerably larger and more interesting than the first. You build a raft to get there.
Airplane Island Brings the Crew Back Together
Airplane Island is where Castaway gets its shape. If you created more than one Sim, you reunite with some of your lost crew here. Once a relationship is strong enough, you can form a tribe. You also find radio parts on this island, and those parts are required for a goal later in the game.
The island hides a secret passage too. The scale of the place is the point. The first island is a beach and a lesson. The second is a jungle with plants, fruits, and wildlife, plus things you can craft and treasures and ancient mysteries buried in it.
You build shelters. You craft items. Your Sims change as they take on the challenges of island life, and the game wants you to notice that change.
Volcano Island, the Llama People, and Two Ways Out
A third island waits. You reach Volcano Island after finding the second beach on Airplane Island and building a canoe. There you discover the remains of the llama people, a detail that lands somewhere between eerie and silly and works anyway.
Volcano Island is also where you decide how the story ends. You can return to civilization two ways:
- Build a boat, or a catamaran once you reach the last beach
- Travel to the volcano’s summit and use the radio parts to send an SOS signal to a nearby ship
There is a third option, and it is optional. You can repair a broken ceremonial forge on Volcano Island. Do that and a fourth island, Crystal Island, rises out of the sea. The game does not require it to escape.
The secrets run deeper than the main path. Hidden Lagoon and the Secret Pirate’s Cove are in the game, but only open once you have gathered the right objects, such as hieroglyphics and treasure map pieces. That process is extensive.
| Island | How you get there | What it holds |
|---|---|---|
| Shipwreck Island | Starting location | First Beach, the goal books |
| Airplane Island | Build a raft | Lost crew, radio parts, a secret passage |
| Volcano Island | Build a canoe | Llama people’s remains, the escape choice, the ceremonial forge |
| Crystal Island | Repair the ceremonial forge | Optional island that rises from the sea |
A Spin-Off That Knew What It Was
Castaway is a simulator, a strategy game, and an adventure game at once, played from a bird’s-eye and isometric view, single player only. The blend is not as messy as it sounds. The survival loop supplies the strategy. The island progression supplies the adventure. The Sims themselves supply the simulation, and the crew system gives the whole thing a reason to exist beyond a single character.
The comparison that matters is with The Sims Castaway Stories, the roughly similar game made for personal computers. Castaway Stories is not a direct port of Castaway, and the two are not interchangeable. The console version is its own thing, built around a controller and a television, and it shows in how the islands are paced.
It is also worth saying what Castaway is not. It is not a full Sims game with a neighborhood, a career ladder, and a house you remodel for forty hours. It is narrower than that, and the narrowness is deliberate.
What Holds Up and What Does Not
The best thing Castaway does is make the crew matter. Choosing an Auto Mechanic or a Chef or a Park Ranger is not just a costume change. Reuniting the crew on Airplane Island and building a tribe gives the middle of the game a goal that is about people rather than resources.
The weak point is the back half. Once you reach Volcano Island, the game hands you a choice between a boat and a radio, and the choice carries less weight than the journey that led to it. Crystal Island is the most interesting thing in the endgame, and it is optional. A game that hides its best final idea behind an optional forge is a game that does not fully trust its own players.
The secret areas have the same problem in reverse. Hidden Lagoon and the Secret Pirate’s Cove are genuine rewards, but getting to them means gathering hieroglyphics and treasure map pieces through an extensive process. The payoff is real. The path to it is long.
None of this breaks the game. Castaway is a spin-off that understood its limits and worked inside them, and it closed out the Sims 2 console line with more care than a licensed tie-in usually gets.
The score sits where the published critical aggregate put it: 7.3 of 10. That number is fair. Castaway is not a landmark, and it is not a misfire. It is a good game with a strong middle, a soft ending, and one optional island that deserved to be mandatory.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
