Tommy Lee Jones plays Andrew Beckett, a successful lawyer whose career collapses after he is diagnosed with AIDS. Denzel Washington plays Joe Miller, the junior attorney who takes on his case despite the stigma. The film follows their fight against discrimination in the legal profession.
Trailer, via Sony Pictures Home Entertainment India.
Andrew Beckett’s Fall
Andrew is a partner at a major law firm. He is told he is being let go for poor performance. Only later does he learn the real reason: he has AIDS. His diagnosis becomes public knowledge, and the firm drops him without warning.
The scene where he learns the truth is quiet but devastating. Jones plays the humiliation with restraint, letting the silence do the work. His face registers the sudden shift from professional confidence to personal ruin in seconds.
Joe Miller’s Choice
Joe is a young lawyer working at a small firm. He has never worked on a high-profile case. When Andrew approaches him about his dismissal, Joe hesitates. He knows the risk of taking on a case that will make him a target. He also knows it is the right thing to do.
Washington plays Joe with warmth and determination. Their scenes together carry the film’s emotional weight. The courtroom scene, where Andrew delivers a speech about his life and work, remains the centerpiece of the film.
The Stigma Around Them
The film does not hide its message. It shows how AIDS was treated as a curse in 1993. People who had it were feared, avoided, and treated as though they carried a mark of shame. The movie asks viewers to feel that fear and prejudice directly.
The film’s message is blunt: AIDS is not a choice, and neither is the way society responds to it. That message lands harder than any subtlety could manage.
Where It Falls Short
The film’s politics are dated now. Its treatment of HIV/AIDS feels like a relic of an earlier era. The film assumes viewers need to be taught what AIDS is and how it spreads. Today, that assumption feels patronizing.
The script also leans heavily on melodrama. Some scenes feel forced, particularly those meant to build tension between Andrew and his colleagues. The film wants to be angry, and sometimes the anger reads as cheap.
A Look Back
| Element | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Performances | Tommy Lee Jones and Denzel Washington deliver strong work | None |
| Message | Clear and urgent in its time | Dated today |
| Structure | Well-paced, building toward the courtroom climax | Some scenes feel forced |
| Setting | Accurately captures the fear around AIDS in 1993 | Over-explains basic facts |
The film’s strengths are real. Jones and Washington give performances that hold up. The courtroom scene remains powerful. But the film’s dated assumptions and heavy-handed approach keep it from greatness.
Philadelphia is a well-made, sincere film that has aged less gracefully than its intentions. It deserves credit for bringing attention to a crisis that was ignored for too long. It does not deserve to be remembered as a great film.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
