WRITTEN IN PLAIN AMERICAN ENGLISH.
About
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

Thirty Years On, The Cure’s Wild Mood Swings Still Can’t Shake Its Singles-and-Filler Formula

A review of The Cure's 1996 double album Wild Mood Swings, weighing its strong singles against its weaker filler.

By mitch·3 min read
A vinyl record spins beneath red and blue stage lights, smoke curling upward.

Wild Mood Swings is The Cure’s 1996 album, a double record built from singles and B-sides stretched across fourteen tracks and sixty-one minutes. It wants to sound wild and scattered, and mostly succeeds — but the wildness is a trick, since the songs themselves are mostly familiar Cure territory, not random chaos. It is an uneven collection, and the best evidence of that is the track list itself.

Opening With Want

The album opens with “Want,” a five-minute piano-led opener that sets the tone for the record: slow, atmospheric, and more patient than anything else on the record. “Club America” follows, a dark, driving track that leans on electronics and builds tension through repetition. Both are strong entries in the Cure catalog, and both are the kind of song that earns the album’s reputation as a collection of singles rather than a unified statement.

“This Is a Lie” and “The 13th” continue the strong streak. “This Is a Lie” is a tense, moody track with a sharp hook, while “The 13th” is darker and more brooding, a track about superstition and fear that holds together well. “Strange Attraction” and “Mint Car” round out the front half of the record, and “Mint Car” is the standout of the pair — a driving, melodic track that shows off the band’s pop instincts.

Advertisement

Middle Stretch

“Jupiter Crash” is a strange, atmospheric track that doesn’t quite land, and “Round & Round & Round…” is a brief, repetitive interlude that passes without much fuss. “Gone!” picks things back up, a track about leaving that has a genuine emotional weight. “Numb” is a moody, atmospheric piece that doesn’t quite reach the heights of the earlier tracks, and “Return” is a quiet, reflective track that closes the middle section without much fanfare.

Back Half

“Trap” and “Treasure” are both solid but unremarkable tracks, neither rising to the level of the singles. “Bare” closes the record at eight minutes, a sprawling, atmospheric track that tries to stretch the album’s themes across its full length. It doesn’t fully succeed, though it has moments that justify the length.

What Works, What Doesn’t

The album’s strongest moments come from the singles, and the singles are where the record earns its reputation. “Want,” “Club America,” “This Is a Lie,” “The 13th,” “Mint Car,” and “Gone!” are all songs that could stand beside anything else in the Cure catalog. The weaker tracks are not failures so much as filler — “Jupiter Crash,” “Round & Round & Round…,” “Numb,” and “Return” are competent but forgettable, and they drag down the overall flow of the record.

An hour-long emptying of poor ideas.

That line captures the frustration of the record’s weaker stretches — there is plenty of ambition here, but ambition alone does not make a great song.

Verdict

Wild Mood Swings is a frustrating, messy record with some genuinely excellent songs buried in the middle. The singles are a highlight reel of the Cure at their best, and the lesser tracks are simply less interesting. It is an album worth hearing for the best moments, but one that does not reward repeated listens from start to finish.

Track Length
Want 5:07
Club America 5:01
This Is a Lie 4:31
The 13th 4:07
Strange Attraction 4:19
Mint Car 3:33
Jupiter Crash 4:16
Round & Round & Round… 2:39
Gone! 4:32
Numb 4:50
Return 3:28
Trap 3:38
Treasure 3:45
Bare 8:02

The record earns its keep on the strength of its singles, but the filler around them drags the whole down. It is a flawed masterpiece — the singles are great, the rest is not.

Score: 7 of 10.

The recordWild Mood Swings The Cure14 tracks · 62 min
  1. Want5:07
  2. Club America5:01
  3. This Is a Lie4:31
  4. The 13th4:07
  5. Strange Attraction4:19
  6. Mint Car3:33
  7. Jupiter Crash4:16
  8. Round & Round & Round…2:39
  9. Gone!4:32
  10. Numb4:50
  11. Return3:28
  12. Trap3:38
  13. Treasure3:45
  14. Bare8:02
More on The Cure
Album reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *