The pitch at the center of Halt and Catch Fire is a strange one: a period drama about the personal computer revolution, built around a fictional Dallas mainframe software company, a visionary, and a plan to clone the IBM PC. AMC let it run for four seasons. Christopher Cantwell and Christopher C. Rogers created the series, which aired in the United States from June 1, 2014, to October 14, 2017, spanning four seasons and 40 episodes.
The show is at its best, in this paper’s view, when it remembers that the revolution was mostly a series of arguments in small rooms.
The title comes from HCF, an idiom for machine code instructions that would cause a computer’s central processing unit to cease meaningful operation, and, in an exaggeration, catch fire. That is the show’s thesis in three words, if you read it that way: everything these people build is one instruction away from burning down.
Trailer, via eOne UK.
Joe MacMillan and the Giant
Lee Pace plays Joe MacMillan. Joe joins Cardiff Electric with a vision of building a computer to challenge IBM, at a moment when IBM is cornering the personal computer market with the IBM PC. He enlists computer engineer Gordon Clark, played by Scoot McNairy, and prodigy programmer Cameron Howe, played by Mackenzie Davis.
The three take advantage of the open architecture of the IBM PC and reverse engineer its BIOS to build a clone called the Giant. Obstacles both internal and external threaten to derail the project. Season one is, to this paper’s eye, the cleanest machine the show ever built: the premise is simple, the stakes are legible, and the tension between Joe’s salesmanship and Gordon’s engineering is real.
McNairy, in this reading, plays Gordon as a man who is right about almost everything and heard about almost nothing. Davis plays Cameron as the only person in the building who understands what the machine should be, which is exactly why nobody wants her in the room.
The casting that built Cardiff
The casting history is worth knowing. David Harbour, Ryan Phillippe and Wes Bentley were considered for Joe. Dakota Johnson and Brie Larson auditioned for Cameron, the role that took the longest to cast. Jimmi Simpson and Jason Mantzoukas auditioned for Gordon, and Karen Gillan was considered for Donna.
McNairy emailed the creators during the process to tell them how the pilot’s story resonated with him, since he grew up in Dallas and his father had been a salesman. That detail is, in this paper’s view, part of why Gordon feels like a person instead of a type.
Mutiny, and the shift to Northern California
Seasons two and three move the show off the mainframe and into a startup called Mutiny, the online community headed by Cameron and by Gordon’s wife Donna, played by Kerry Bishé. Joe ventures out on his own.
This is where Halt and Catch Fire stops being a show about building a computer and starts being a show about the people who build computers, a harder and less tidy thing, as this paper sees it. The relocation matters more than the plot does, in our reading.
Cantwell and Rogers moved the setting to Northern California and created the character of Ryan Ray, an Indian-American computer programmer native to San Francisco, played by Manish Dayal, to match the change in demographic. That is, to this paper’s eye, a rare instance of a show adjusting its cast to its own geography rather than pretending the geography is neutral.
Aleksa Palladino joined as a regular for season two, with James Cromwell and Mark O’Brien as recurring. Matthew Lillard and Annabeth Gish came aboard in recurring roles for season three. The fourth and final season focuses on competing web search engines involving all the principal characters. In this paper’s judgment, that is the right ending and the wrong shape: search is a business, not a machine, and the show’s best instinct has always been mechanical.
What the four seasons actually do
The show’s arc is not a rise or a fall. It is a rotation. The partnerships shift, the competitive relationships shift, and the personal costs of pursuing professional ambitions keep landing on people who did not sign up for them. Toby Huss plays John “Bos” Bosworth across the whole run, and he reads, to this paper, as the show’s ballast, the one character who seems to understand that a company is just a group of people who agreed to show up.
Here is this paper’s ranking of the seasons, offered as opinion and not as anything the source establishes:
- Season one, the Giant project, the clearest goal, the tightest run of episodes.
- Season two, Mutiny’s early days, and the best use of Donna as a protagonist rather than a spouse.
- Season four, the search engine war, ambitious but diffuse.
- Season three, the transition season, necessary and uneven.
That ordering is not a knock on season three. It is a knock on the fact that the show needed a season whose only job was to move everyone to California.
| Era | Company | Central conflict |
|---|---|---|
| Season one | Cardiff Electric | Reverse engineering the IBM PC to build the Giant |
| Seasons two and three | Mutiny | Running an online community as a startup |
| Season four | Competing search engines | All principal characters, head to head |
Where the show loses its nerve
Halt and Catch Fire was the first job Cantwell and Rogers ever had in the television industry. They wrote the pilot hoping to use it to land work as writers and instead got their own series with AMC. You can feel that in the first season, the hunger, the willingness to explain things.
David Wilson Barnes was cast as Dale Butler and credited among the main cast in the pilot, and his character was written out after just two episodes when the story went in a different direction. This paper reads that as a small sign of a show still finding its shape. The source does not connect the Barnes exit to the later seasons, and neither do we.
The show’s central insight holds all the way through, in this paper’s view. The personal computer revolution was not won by the smartest people. It was won by the people who could stand to keep working with each other.
The verdict on Halt and Catch Fire
This is, in this paper’s assessment, a good show that was never a great one, and the gap between those two things is almost entirely structural. Halt and Catch Fire has one of the best premises AMC ever put on air and one of the weakest second halves. The Giant is a goal. Mutiny is a goal. Search engines are a market, and markets do not make for drama the way a machine does. That is our argument, not the source’s.
What saves it, to this paper’s eye, is the cast. Pace, McNairy, Davis, Bishé and Huss are all doing work that is better than the scripts in seasons three and four. This paper recommends the show for the first season alone, and for finishing it for the performances. It is a period drama that understands the period, the early 1980s into the early 1990s, a depicted span of more than ten years, without ever turning into a costume parade.
The published critical score is 7.3/10 (Metacritic 73/100).
That number is right, and this paper thinks it is right for a specific reason. Halt and Catch Fire is a show about people who build things that outlive them, made by people who never quite figured out how to make the building itself the story. The first season does, in our view. The rest of it remembers.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.