Boog is a 900-pound bear who thinks he runs the show in Timberline. He lives with Beth, the ranger who raised him, and stars in the town’s nature program. When Shaw, a hunter with a one-antlered deer named Elliot tied to his truck, rolls into town, Boog’s world gets turned upside down. Elliot escapes, and Boog, who has no idea how to survive in the woods, agrees to be his guide.
Trailer, via Sony Pictures Animation.
The Setup in Timberline
The setup is simple and effective. Boog is comfortable in his concrete life until Shaw forces him out. The problem is that once Boog is in the forest, the movie stops building on that premise. Instead it fills the remaining hours with a ragged, unstructured adventure that never quite commits to being funny, moving, or even coherent.
Elliot is a fast-talking deer with a one antler. He convinces Boog to break out of the garage and raid a local convenience store. That scene is the film’s high point, a moment of genuine chemistry between the two leads. Then the movie loses focus.
Squirrels, Beavers, and a Long Road Home
The forest is full of animals who don’t want to help. There’s McSquizzy, a Scottish-accented squirrel who throws acorns at Boog. There’s Reilly, a beaver. And there’s a whole gang of forest creatures who treat Boog and Elliot like trespassers. The movie leans on these encounters for laughs, but the jokes land inconsistently. Some are clever, others feel forced.
The pacing suffers too. The middle stretch drags as Boog and Elliot wander through the woods, meeting new animals and avoiding hunters. Shaw keeps showing up, but his pursuit feels less like a threat and more like a way to fill time between set pieces.
Voice Work and the Cast
Martin Lawrence plays Boog with the kind of physical comedy that works better live-action than animated. Ashton Kutcher is fine as Elliot, though his rapid-fire delivery sometimes reads as frantic rather than funny. Gary Sinise voices Shaw, Debra Messing voices Beth, and Billy Connolly voices McSquizzy. Jon Favreau, Jane Krakowski, Gordon Tootoosis, Patrick Warburton, Cody Cameron, and Nika Futterman round out the cast.
The voice acting is competent across the board, but the script doesn’t give anyone room to shine. Character arcs are thin. Boog learns nothing from his ordeal. Elliot stays one-note. Shaw remains a cartoonish villain without menace. The film wants to be about friendship and survival, but it never digs deep enough to earn those themes.
Where It Falls Short
“Open Season” is a film that knows how to start but not how to finish. The opening hour has energy and some sharp gags. The final act, which should resolve the hunt and bring Boog home, instead settles for a rushed conclusion that barely lands. The tagline promises “One fur all. All fur one.” The movie delivers neither.
The animation is serviceable. Nothing stands out visually. The humor is broad and aimed at kids, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but the film doesn’t seem to know its target audience. It’s too loud for older viewers and too simple for younger ones.
There’s also a structural issue. The film is 86 minutes long, but it feels far longer because of how much ground it covers without ever settling on a central conflict. Shaw’s pursuit, the forest animals, and Boog’s attempts to get home all fight for attention in a space that can’t contain them.
A Mixed Bag With Little Payoff
“Open Season” is a mixed bag with little payoff. It has a promising setup, a decent voice cast, and a few genuine laughs. But it never builds on its own premise, and the result is a film that feels unfinished even at its stated runtime.
Key Facts
– Directed by Roger Allers and Jill Culton
– Written by Nat Mauldin, Steve Bencich, and Ron J. Friedman
– Runtime: 86 minutes
– Voices include Martin Lawrence, Ashton Kutcher, Gary Sinise, and Debra Messing
– Grossed $201 million against an $85 million budget
The film’s mixed reception is reflected in its financial performance. It made $201 million against an $85 million budget, which is respectable but modest for an animated release. The franchise continued with three sequels, but none of them matched the promise of this debut.
“Open Season” is a forgettable entry in the animated genre. It has moments of charm and a strong start, but it fails to deliver a satisfying payoff. The forest animals are a missed opportunity, and the hunt never reaches the tension it promises. Boog and Elliot deserve better than this.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
