ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

Flower is not a game you beat. It is a game you finish, and the difference is the entire point.

Flower, Thatgamecompany's 2009 PlayStation Network game about wind, petals and color, has no fail state and no text — and that restraint is the point.

By mitch·3 min read
A wind-shaped avatar moves through a field of dead brown grass near a glowing flower.

Flower is a game about wind, petals and color, and it has no interest in whether you win. Thatgamecompany released it in February 2009 on the PlayStation Network, and it remains one of the strangest things Sony ever published.

Six Flowers on a Windowsill

The structure is simple. Flower is divided into six main levels and one credits level, each represented by a flower in a pot on a city apartment windowsill. Pick one and you enter that flower’s dream.

Inside, you control the wind, blowing a single petal through the air. Tilting the PlayStation 3 controller handles pitch and roll. Pressing any button blows harder and moves the petal faster. The camera sits just behind the petal, occasionally drifting to show a new objective or the consequence of what you just did.

Advertisement

The Swarm Grows

Fly near flowers and they bloom, and a new petal trails yours. The more petals you collect, the faster the whole stream moves. Certain flowers change the world outright: dead grass turns bright green, new areas open, wind turbines start spinning. Each bloom lands as a musical chime that harmonizes with the score, and the music itself shifts as the world changes.

It is impossible for the player to lose a level or any progress.

No enemies. No hit points. No time limits. A single play-through runs about an hour.

Jenova Chen’s Argument

Jenova Chen designed Flower with Nicholas Clark, and the intent was to arouse positive emotions rather than to challenge. Chen felt entertainment products like games were defined by the feelings they produced, and that most games worked a very narrow emotional range. The team treated the project as a work of art.

That ambition shows in what Flower refuses to do. There is no text or dialogue anywhere outside the credits and menu hints. The six dreams still trace a narrative arc, carried by image and mood — each stage opens near where the last one ended.

Bluepoint and Annapurna

Bluepoint Games ported Flower to PlayStation 4 and PlayStation Vita in November 2013. An iOS version followed in September 2017, and a Windows version in February 2019, both published by Annapurna Interactive. The game began as a spiritual successor to Flow, Chen and Thatgamecompany’s earlier title.

Freedom as the Actual Mechanic

The pitch is that Flower is about doing what you want, when you want, and the design backs it up. Levels carry their own aims and small mysteries, but nothing forces you to solve them. Flight, exploration and contact with the world are the whole of it.

That still reads as a real position rather than a marketing line. Most games treat the player’s attention as something to be captured and held. Flower treats it as something to be spent freely, and trusts you to come back.

What Flower Gets Right

The restraint is the achievement. A game with no fail state, no text and roughly an hour of play could easily read as a sketch, and Flower does not. The dynamic score and the petal swarm do the work that dialogue would do elsewhere, and the transitions between dreams give the arc a shape without a single line of exposition.

The limit is real too. An hour is an hour, and players who need friction or difficulty will find Flower thin. The version released on Windows and iOS reaches further than the PlayStation 3 original did, but the audience that wants a challenge was never the audience here.

Flower is not a game you beat. It is a game you finish, and the difference is the entire point.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Game reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.