Call of Cthulhu asks players to solve a mystery, and it mostly delivers on that promise. The 2018 survival horror game, available on PS4, PC, Xbox One and Switch, puts players in the role of a private investigator trying to unravel a case in New Orleans. The result is a game that respects the source material while struggling to make its systems feel distinct.
Trailer, via IGDBcom.
A Detective’s Case
The premise is simple: a detective investigates a strange death in New Orleans. The investigation leads to cults, hidden histories and the creeping presence of Lovecraftian horrors. Players gather clues, question witnesses and make deductions to advance the story. That core loop works well, giving the game a sense of purpose that some survival horrors lack.
Combat and Stealth
Combat is a weak point. Enemies are aggressive, health is scarce and encounters often feel unfair. Stealth can help, but the game does not explain its systems clearly. Players are left guessing whether a crouch or a fight is the better call, which takes away from the tension the genre promises.
Atmosphere Over Action
The setting is the game’s strongest asset. New Orleans is rendered with a sense of decay and dread, and the city’s streets feel lived-in rather than sterile. Sound design carries much of the weight, with distant chanting and strange noises building suspense even when nothing is on screen.
The Writing
Dialogue is a mixed bag. Some conversations land with wit and dread, while others feel flat and mechanical. The script leans heavily on exposition, and players who skip text boxes risk losing plot threads entirely. The game also suffers from pacing issues, with stretches of wandering and searching that do little to advance the story.
Performance Across Platforms
The game runs on four platforms, and performance varies widely. On PC and console, frame rates hold steady during quieter moments but dip in dense environments. The Switch version is the weakest link, with noticeable slowdown during combat scenes.
Comparing the Ports
| Platform | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| PS4/Xbox One | Stable performance | Long load times |
| PC | Highest fidelity | System requirements |
| Switch | Portable convenience | Lowest performance |
| All | Shared save data | Limited visual detail |
Key Facts
- Title: Call of Cthulhu
- Release Year: 2018
- Platforms: PS4, PC, Xbox One, Switch
- Developer: Cyanide
- Critical Score: 6.5/10
Where It Falls Short
The game’s ambition exceeds its execution in several areas. Combat mechanics are underdeveloped, stealth is poorly explained and pacing issues drag out the middle of the story. These flaws keep Call of Cthulhu from reaching the heights of its source material.
The Final Word
Call of Cthulhu is a solid, if flawed, adaptation of Lovecraft’s world. Its detective framework gives it a clear goal, and its atmosphere rewards players willing to explore. But combat frustrations and pacing issues keep it from greatness.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
