Damien Chazelle has spent his career building films about men who chase a single moment until it breaks them. First Man hands him the largest version of that story available to an American director, and he answers with his quietest, hardest film. Ryan Gosling plays Neil Armstrong across the nine years that run from a bad bounce off the atmosphere in an X-15 to a boot print in lunar dust on July 20, 1969. The film premiered at the Venice Film Festival on August 29, 2018, reached US theaters on October 12 through Universal Pictures, and grossed $105.7 million worldwide against a $59 million production budget.
That gap between acclaim and ticket sales is the first thing to sort out, because it shaped how the movie was talked about for years afterward.
Trailer, via Universal Pictures.
Ryan Gosling Plays Neil Armstrong as a Man Closing a Door
Chazelle’s Armstrong is not a hero who gives speeches. He is a man who loses his 2-year-old daughter Karen to a brain tumor, keeps a detailed log of her symptoms while she is sick, and then applies to Project Gemini. Gosling plays the grief as a kind of engineering: nothing shows on the surface, everything is stored.
Josh Singer wrote the screenplay from James R. Hansen’s 2005 book First Man: The Life of Neil A. Armstrong. Singer’s script keeps the domestic scenes as weighted as the flight sequences. Janet Armstrong, played by Claire Foy, carries most of the film’s open anger. Foy gets the film’s hardest domestic moments, and she does not soften them.
The supporting cast is deep and mostly underused, which is a real cost.
- Jason Clarke as Ed White, the first American to walk in space
- Kyle Chandler as Deke Slayton, NASA’s first Chief of the Astronaut Office
- Corey Stoll as Buzz Aldrin, the second man on the Moon
- Patrick Fugit as Elliot See, killed in a 1966 T-38 crash in St. Louis
- Ciarán Hinds as Bob Gilruth, first director of the Manned Spacecraft Center
- Lukas Haas as Mike Collins, Command Module Pilot for Apollo 11
Clarke’s Ed White is the film’s warmest presence, and the film uses him to set up a death the audience already knows is coming. White died in a pre-launch test for Apollo 1, the mission meant to be the first crewed Apollo flight. Shea Whigham’s Gus Grissom dies in the same test.
A Space Race Told Through Failure After Failure
The film’s structure is a list of losses. Slayton tells the new astronauts that the Soviet Union had reached every milestone in the Space Race ahead of the United States. Then the film proves it. The Soviets complete the first extravehicular activity in 1965. Armstrong gets Gemini 8 with David Scott as pilot, docks with the Agena target vehicle, and then a malfunction sends the spacecraft rolling at an increasingly dangerous rate.
Armstrong nearly blacks out, fires the RCS thrusters, and aborts. He faces criticism. NASA clears the crew and rates the mission a success. Chazelle shoots the sequence tight and disorienting, and it is the best argument the film makes for its own approach: space here is not wonder, it is a machine trying to kill you while you fix it.
See and Charles Bassett die in a T-38 crash before Gemini 8 launches. Armstrong’s grief compounds with each name. By the time Apollo 11 arrives, the audience has been trained to expect the worst, which is exactly the tension the Moon landing sequence needs.
The Moon Landing Is the Sequence That Earns the Runtime
The climax runs long and Chazelle lets it. The lunar surface is shot to feel physical rather than majestic, and the visual effects work is the film’s most defensible technical achievement. It won Best Visual Effects at the 91st Academy Awards, one of its four nominations.
Christopher Abbott’s Dave Scott, Pablo Schreiber’s Jim Lovell as backup commander, and Stoll’s Aldrin fill out the mission. Stoll’s Aldrin reads as a man with little patience for ceremony, which is a useful counterweight to Gosling’s stillness. The two of them in the cramped cabin are the film’s sharpest pairing, and the movie knows it.
At 141 minutes, First Man is patient to the point of severity. Some stretches between missions drag. The film is a history and a drama, and it leans harder on the second than most space movies bother to.
What First Man Gets Right That Other Space Films Do Not
Most films about Apollo treat the mission as the point. First Man treats the mission as the bill. Armstrong’s application to Gemini comes after Karen’s death, and the film never lets you forget the order of those events. The Moon is what he does instead of grieving.
That reading is not subtle, and Chazelle does not pretend it is. But it holds the whole movie together, including the parts that feel like a checklist of NASA milestones. The film’s tagline is “One giant leap into the unknown,” and the film’s actual subject is narrower and better: a man who has already been somewhere unknown and did not come back the same.
The project had a long road. It was announced in 2003 with Clint Eastwood slated to direct. That version fell through. Chazelle, Gosling and Singer were all signed by 2015, and principal photography began in Atlanta in November 2017.
The Case Against First Man
The film underperformed, and the reasons are not mysterious. It is a $59 million drama about grief that happens to contain a Moon landing, sold to audiences as a Moon landing. That mismatch was noise, and it was the wrong conversation.
The real weakness is thinner. Foy’s Janet is the only character outside Armstrong who gets a full interior life, and the film could have used one more. The astronaut wives exist mostly as a chorus. Olivia Hamilton’s Pat White gets a few good beats and then recedes. The film’s restraint, which is its strength in the cockpit, becomes a limitation in the living room.
But restraint is also the reason the final act lands. First Man does not tell you how to feel about the Moon. It shows you a man who has spent nine years being told what the cost is, and then it shows him paying it.
This is a film whose reputation has room to grow past its box office. The direction is controlled, the performances are exact, and the Moon landing sequence is the rare set piece that justifies its own length. First Man is not Chazelle’s most exciting film. It is his most adult one, and the difference matters.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
