American Hostage is a TV show about a hostage situation in Indianapolis in 1977. It stars Jon Hamm as Fred Heckman, a radio legend who gets pulled back into journalism after a man named Tony Kiritsis takes Dick Hall hostage in a mortgage office. The series is based on a podcast from Criminal Content, and it was created by Shawn Ryan and Eileen Myers, who also made The Night Agent. It streams on MGM+.
The show opens with promise. Hamm plays Heckman as a man who has stopped caring about reporting, content to deliver news on the radio without digging for it. Ribisi plays Kiritsis as a used-car salesman turned criminal who believes Dick Hall and his family stole his money through a bad mortgage. The hostage situation forces Heckman to reconnect with the work that once defined him.
The Setup
The show is set in 1977, a year that matters for the story. Tony Kiritsis walks into a mortgage office, takes Dick Hall hostage, and accuses the Hall family of giving him a loan they knew he could not pay back. His goal is simple: an apology, immunity, and the chance to buy the land he wanted to build a steakhouse on.
Kiritsis wants a restaurant that is fancy but open to everyone. He is a good neighbor and a good brother. He is also a mess of a man who expresses himself in loud, intense ways. The show contrasts his nervous energy with Polaha’s quiet resignation. Polaha plays Dick Hall as a man whose life is interrupted by a hostage situation he did not deserve.
The situation escalates fast. Local police, troubled by rumors of departmental wrongdoing, want a peaceful end. Federal authorities consider extreme action. In a country still stinging from Watergate and the counterculture movement, Kiritsis becomes famous as quickly as anyone could have expected.
Hamm and Ribisi Carry It
Hamm and Ribisi are the reason this show works at all. Hamm plays Heckman as a sincere and genuine man who has been hollowed out by personal tragedy. Ribisi plays Kiritsis as a mess of a man who is also a good neighbor and a good brother. The captor-captive dynamic gets plenty of screen time, and it is the best part of the show.
The supporting cast is strong too. William Jackson Harper plays Ben Hairston, a co-worker who worries about Heckman’s sense of journalistic ethics. June Laporte plays Ginny, an aspiring reporter who needs proper mentoring. Kat Cunning plays Ibby, Dick Hall’s wife. Mireille Enos plays Barbara, Heckman’s wife.
What Goes Wrong
The problem is that the show does not resolve its own story. The early episodes set up a modern resonance — the hostage-taker’s complaint about rigged systems echoes Luigi Mangione’s killing of a healthcare executive, an act many people saw as an understandable expression of rage. Kiritsis’ crime, committed with a shotgun attached to a dead man’s switch, is meant to resonate similarly.
But the show runs out of things to say. The sixth episode fragments into a flashback loop that reduces everyone to interchangeable daddy issues. The writers never return to the pragmatic approach to journalistic ethics they hinted at in the early episodes. The show’s nervousness about FCC crackdowns and government interference in the news-gathering apparatus goes nowhere.
“The series has a lot of initial fun with the mechanics of 1970s radio — phone-call transferring and impromptu recordings, with a technological fascination that reminded me of the Munich Olympics drama September 5 — and hints at a pragmatic approach to journalistic ethics, only to go nowhere with it.”
The Middle Sags
The middle episodes are where the show loses focus. Harper’s Ben is presented as the show’s moral compass, and Laporte’s Ginny is its heart. By the end, both characters are stranded. The show commits to a direction — that the people covering the story are not the real story — but then leaves those characters behind without giving them anywhere to go.
Enos’ Barbara and Kat Cunning’s Ibby step forward to take up the prominence that the journalistic side of the story has surrendered. Barbara and Ibby forge a friendship that is unexpectedly compelling. But the show never gives Harper’s Ben or Laporte’s Ginny the payoff they earned.
Where It Lands
American Hostage is a show with lots of potential and little payoff. It is well acted, over-extended, and mostly a nostalgic trip back to landline telephones and manageable institutional corruption. The show calls to mind Sidney Lumet’s Dog Day Afternoon, and it shares that film’s themes of distrust toward authority. It also draws on the recent Broadway adaptation of Dog Day Afternoon, which aggressively underlined the period’s paranoia and suspicion toward establishment power as timeless and contemporary.
The show is at its best when it stays close to the hostage situation itself. The captor-captive dynamic is a good one, and Ribisi’s performance carries it. But the show’s ambitions — a commentary on journalism, a commentary on systemic corruption, a commentary on the nature of fame — all go unresolved.
The Verdict
The show is a disappointment. The performances are strong, but the story stalls. The creators set up a modern resonance and then let it go. The show’s best moments — the phone-call transfers, the impromptu recordings, the contrast between Kiritsis’s energy and Polaha’s resignation — are scattered across eight episodes that never quite come together.
Here is how the show’s strengths and weaknesses break down:
- Strong performances from Hamm and Ribisi
- A compelling captor-captive dynamic
- Interesting supporting characters in Harper and Laporte
- Nostalgia for 1970s radio that is technically fascinating
- Unresolved storylines and a stalled ending
The show is worth watching for the acting and the premise. But the payoff never arrives. The creators set up a kidnapping thriller with modern resonance and then let it go. The show is a reminder that a good idea is not enough. A show needs to stick the landing, and American Hostage does not.
The show is available to stream on MGM+. If you are interested in radio dramas, hostage situations, or 1970s Americana, it is worth a look. But be prepared for a story that never quite resolves itself.
Source material: “‘American Hostage’ Review: Jon Hamm and Giovanni Ribisi in an MGM+ Kidnapping Thriller With Lots of Potential but Little Payoff,” The Hollywood Reporter.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.