Martin Odum is not a man with a secret identity. He is a man with several of them. That is the premise of Legends, TNT’s 2014 crime drama about an FBI agent who can transform himself into anyone else for a job, and the show spends two seasons trying to decide whether that skill is a gift or a curse. The result is a series that is clever in theory and often muddled in practice, a show that understands its own rules better than it executes them.
Legends follows Martin Odum, played by Sean Bean, as he works for the FBI’s Deep Cover Operations division. His assignments include posing as a Serbian extremist, a corrupt Chicago police officer, a British special forces colonel, and a legendary computer hacker. The twist is that Odum has spent his entire adult life doing this work, and he has no memory of who he was before he became an agent. When he learns that his life itself may be a lie, he faces a demand: the job he was built for, or the mystery of his identity. And given the choice between the two, Odum doesn’t always make the right decision.
Trailer, via IGN.
The Premise
The show is based on Robert Littell’s 2005 novel Legends: A Novel of Dissimulation, and it borrows the book’s central idea: a man who can become anyone. The premise is simple and elegant. Odum’s ability is not superhuman strength or telekinesis; it is mimicry, observation, and acting. He watches people, copies their mannerisms, and becomes them. That specificity is the show’s greatest strength. It is also the thing that Legends struggles to live up to.
The show was created by Howard Gordon, Jeffrey Nachmanoff, and Mark Bomback. It aired on TNT from August 13, 2014, to December 28, 2015, across two seasons and 20 episodes. On December 4, 2014, TNT renewed Legends for a 10-episode second season, which premiered on November 2, 2015. On December 15, 2015, TNT canceled the series after two seasons and 20 episodes.
Sean Bean’s Martin Odum
Sean Bean plays Martin Odum as a man who is constantly slipping through the cracks of his own life. He is a professional liar who cannot tell the truth to himself. Bean brings a quiet intensity to the role, and his performance is the reason the show works at all. He is believable as both the agent and the man behind the mask, even when the script asks him to switch identities within minutes.
The supporting cast includes Steve Kazee as Curtis Ballard, Winter Ave Zoli as Gabriela Mišková, Klára Issová as Ilyana Crawford, Aisling Franciosi as Kate Crawford, Kelly Overton as Nina Brenner, and Ralph Brown as Terrence Graves. Billy Brown plays a mysterious stranger who causes Odum to question his sanity. The ensemble is capable, but the show does not give them enough to do beyond reacting to Odum’s revelations.
The Identity Problem
The core tension of Legends is Odum’s struggle to know who he is. He has been undercover for so long that he has lost touch with his original self. The show wants us to feel the weight of that loss, but it is hampered by a lack of clarity about what the original Martin Odum would have been like. We see glimpses of a family, a wife, a normal life, but the show never commits to what that life looked like. The ambiguity is meant to be unsettling, but it often just feels unfinished.
The show also introduces a conspiracy involving the FBI and a cover-up. Odum’s father is revealed to have been a spy, and the show suggests that Odum’s memories may have been fabricated as part of that cover-up. This adds a layer of generational betrayal that could have been compelling.
The Mysterious Stranger
Billy Brown’s mysterious stranger is supposed to be the catalyst for Odum’s breakdown. He appears out of nowhere, knows things about Odum that no one else should know, and tells Odum that his memories are fake. The problem is that the show never explains who this stranger is or why he exists. He is a plot device, not a character. Brown is a good actor, but he is given nothing to work with.
The stranger’s presence raises questions that the show never answers. Is he a former colleague of Odum’s father? A supernatural entity? The show leaves all options open, which is frustrating rather than mysterious. A good conspiracy thriller builds its mystery brick by brick; Legends throws a brick at the viewer and hopes they will figure out the pattern.
The Second Season
The second season picks up where the first left off, with Odum digging deeper into his past. The show explores the conspiracy further, though the source material does not specify the full shape of the plot. The season also introduces a new antagonist in Terrence Graves, played by Ralph Brown, whose role is not detailed in the provided source.
The second season is more focused than the first, but it is also more cynical. The show stops being interested in Odum’s humanity and starts being interested in his skills. The finale, which aired on December 28, 2015, closes the series.
The Technical Craft
On a technical level, Legends is well-made. The production design is solid, the costumes are detailed, and the direction keeps the pacing tight. The show knows how to stage an action sequence and how to shoot a tense conversation. It also knows how to use flashbacks effectively, cutting between Odum’s current assignment and the memories he is trying to recover.
The show’s weakness is in its writing. The dialogue is functional but flat, and the plotting is predictable. When Odum has to choose between his job and his identity, the show never gives him a difficult choice. It gives him an easy one, and then it punishes him for making the obvious decision. The show is smarter than its scripts let on.
The Cancellation
TNT canceled Legends after two seasons and 20 episodes. The show had modest ratings, and its renewal in December 2014 was a surprise. The cancellation in December 2015 was not. The show had run out of ideas, and the network had run out of patience.
The ending of the show is a disappointment. It leaves the mystery unresolved and the characters adrift. The final episode ends the series without answering all of its questions.
What Works
Legends is not a great show, but it is not a bad one either. It has moments of genuine tension and a central performance that holds the whole thing together. The show’s best episodes are the ones that focus on Odum’s relationships with other people. The worst episodes are the ones that focus on the conspiracy.
Here is what the show does well:
- Sean Bean’s performance as Martin Odum.
- The premise of a man who can become anyone.
- The production design and visual style.
- The use of flashbacks to build tension.
And here is what the show does poorly:
- The writing is flat and predictable.
- The identity mystery is never fully explained.
- The mysterious stranger is a wasted character.
- The second season loses focus on Odum’s humanity.
The Verdict
Legends is a show that is better than its reputation. It is not a masterpiece, but it is not a failure either. It is a show that tried to do something unusual and mostly succeeded, even as it stumbled over its own ambitions. The show’s score reflects that balance.
The show deserves credit for taking risks. It is rare for a network to commission a show about an undercover agent who is also a fugitive from his own history. The show’s willingness to ask uncomfortable questions about identity and memory is commendable, even when the answers arrive late or never at all.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
