Bloober Team built a horror game around a dog, a camcorder, and a man coming apart in the woods. Blair Witch, released in 2019, sends players into Black Hills Forest near Burkittsville, Maryland, as Ellis Lynch, a former police officer and veteran searching for a missing nine-year-old boy named Peter Shannon.
It is a first-person survival horror game. It is also, more often than its combat or its puzzles, a study of a man who cannot stop remembering the worst things he has done.
Trailer, via XBOX.
Ellis Lynch and the Weight of Black Hills Forest
The game opens in 1996, two years after the events of The Blair Witch Project. Ellis arrives with Bullet, his police dog, to join the search party. Sheriff Emmet Lanning, a close friend, checks in on him regularly and worries about his PTSD.
That worry is the story. Ellis has dissociative amnesia. He has forgotten a childhood friend who vanished in the same forest. He served in the Gulf War, watched his squad die, and accidentally killed an innocent woman. After his discharge he became a police officer, married a woman named Jess, and then killed a burglar during a PTSD episode. The burglar was Peter’s brother, Adam. Jess left. Lanning gave him Bullet.
Ellis joins the search to relieve his guilt over Adam’s death. The game never lets him, or the player, forget it.
Bullet, Cassette Tapes, and a Camcorder That Rewinds Time
The mechanics carry the theme. Bullet is not a prop. Players command the dog through a menu, feed him treats from the backpack, and use him to track scents and reach crevices Ellis cannot fit into. He is the most useful tool in the game and the only warm thing in it.
The camcorder does the stranger work. Players find red and blue cassette tapes. Blue tapes tell more of the story. Red tapes let Ellis manipulate and rewind time to move objects that have been locked or shifted out of place. It is the found-footage idea from the films turned into a puzzle device, and it is easily the most interesting thing Blair Witch does.
The backpack fills with wooden dolls, polaroids of missing people, dog tags, and psychiatrist notes. Blocked paths open through puzzles or item collection. Ellis carries a cell phone and a walkie-talkie, and calls can be accepted or rejected. That choice affects the ending. The phone menu also holds Snake and Astro Blaster, two 2D games playable at any point.
What Works and What Fights You
The atmosphere holds. The forest warps and distorts time and space. Silhouetted creatures attack near a crooked white tree with black vines, and Ellis can scare them off with his flashlight. The sound design and the graphics do their job.
The gameplay design is where Blair Witch stumbles. Stealth and survival horror mechanics sit awkwardly against the semi-open world, and the difficulty curve is uneven. The game asks players to react to danger and behave under pressure, and then punishes them for reading its rules correctly. The camera work that should feel like discovery starts to feel like busywork.
| Element | What Blair Witch does |
|---|---|
| Companion | Bullet, a dog commanded through a menu, fed treats, used to track scent |
| Time mechanic | Red cassette tapes rewind time to move locked objects |
| Story mechanic | Blue cassette tapes reveal more of the plot |
| Extra content | Snake and Astro Blaster playable on Ellis’ phone |
A Verdict on Blair Witch
The pieces that matter most are the ones Bloober Team got right. Ellis is a specific man with a specific history, voiced by Joseph May, and the game treats his trauma as the point rather than as set dressing. Bullet earns his place. The red tape mechanic is a genuine idea, not a gimmick.
What holds Blair Witch back is the space between those ideas and the moment-to-moment play. The puzzles, the blocked paths, and the stealth encounters too often interrupt the descent instead of deepening it. The game knows what it is about. It does not always trust the player to feel it without being tested first.
That gap is why Blair Witch lands as a flawed, memorable game rather than a great one. It is worth playing for the tapes, the dog, and the version of Ellis that the ending forces you to confront. It is not worth playing for the combat.
KEY FACTS
– Release year: 2019
– Developer and publisher: Bloober Team (Wikipedia lists Lionsgate Games as publisher)
– Platforms: PlayStation 4, PC (Microsoft Windows), Xbox One, Nintendo Switch
– Genre: Survival horror, first person, single player
– Setting: Black Hills Forest, Burkittsville, Maryland, 1996
– Protagonist: Ellis Lynch, voiced by Joseph May
– Published critical score: 7.2/10 (IGDB critic aggregate, 11 outlets)
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
