Silent Hill: Shattered Memories came out in December 2009 for the Wii, then reached the PlayStation 2 and PlayStation Portable the following January. It is the seventh entry in Konami’s survival horror series and a full reimagining of the first Silent Hill, not a remake. Climax Studios kept Harry Mason and his missing daughter. It threw out nearly everything else.
Trailer, via NintendoRAW.
Harry Mason Wakes Up in the Snow
The premise survives. Harry crashes his car and wakes to find seven-year-old Cheryl gone. He walks the snowy streets of the fictitious American town of Silent Hill looking for her. Then the world freezes over and the demons come.
That is where the familiar part ends. Shattered Memories sits in a different fictional universe with a different plot, altered characters and new ones. Five endings are available. The personalities and roles of the original cast have been changed outright.
The biggest change is combat. There is none. Weapons are gone. When the monsters come out, Harry runs. That single decision reshapes every encounter in the game.
Dr. Michael Kaufmann Asks the Questions
The gameplay splits in two. One half is a first-person psychotherapy session in Dr. Michael Kaufmann’s office. The other is Harry’s journey through Silent Hill in an over-the-shoulder view.
In the office, the player answers Kaufmann’s questions, completes a psychological test, fills in a questionnaire or colors pictures. The responses change the second half. They alter available areas, the physical appearance and behavior of characters, and the look of the monsters. The game returns to the office periodically throughout.
The stated intent is discomfort aimed at the specific player. Characters and lines of dialog shift based on what you answered. Shattered Memories wants the therapy to follow you back into the town.
A Smartphone, a Flashlight, and Radio Noise
Harry carries a smartphone and a flashlight. The phone handles the GPS map, photographs and telephone calls. Standing in spots with heavy interference, marked by radio noise, or photographing places where shadowy figures appear, unlocks text and voicemail messages. Those messages expand the story and sometimes hand over clues. Players can zoom in on objects to read documents.
The Nightmare is the other half of the horror. Silent Hill’s alter-dimension becomes a world of ice, and the lumbering demons chase Harry through it. His only answer is to run.
- Wii release: December 2009
- PlayStation 2 and PlayStation Portable ports: January 2010
- PlayStation Network in Europe: April 2014
- Endings: five
- Critic aggregate: 7.5/10 across 6 outlets
Cybil Bennett, Dahlia Mason, and the Town That Keeps Changing
The plot runs on people who are not who they were a scene ago. Officer Cybil Bennett picks Harry up and gets caught in a blizzard. He leaves her car to keep searching. At the high school, Michelle Valdez tells him a Cheryl Mason once attended, then moved, and offers a ride to the new address. He steps away. He comes back to Dahlia Mason, who says she is his lover and acts as if she has been there the whole time.
He takes the ride anyway. During another shift to the Nightmare, the car goes into a river. He wakes in a wheelchair, pushed by Cybil, in the town hospital. She is about to tell him about his file at the station when the town shifts again. He meets Lisa Garland, a nurse injured in a crash, and walks her home. She asks for pills for her headache. He gives them to her. He returns to find her dead or dying, depending on what the player did.
Harry escapes to Cheryl’s home and finds an older Dahlia, who says she is his wife.
None of this is decoration. The game is asking what kind of person Harry actually is, and it withholds the answer until the therapy sessions have done their work.
What Shattered Memories Gets Right
Akira Yamaoka composed the soundtrack, the first in the series to lean hard on dynamic music. The score responds to what is happening on screen rather than sitting under it. Reviews were generally positive on the graphics, the plot, the voice acting and the music.
The removal of combat is the brave call, and it holds up. A survival horror game that takes away your gun has to make fleeing feel like a system instead of a punishment. Shattered Memories does. The frozen Nightmare is a clean, readable threat, and the radio noise that marks interference turns the smartphone into an instrument of dread rather than a menu.
The therapy frame is the part worth arguing about. It is the most interesting idea in the game and the least controlled one. Tying character appearances and dialog to a questionnaire is a real mechanism, not a gimmick, but it means the story bends toward whatever the player admitted in a doctor’s office. Sometimes that lands. Sometimes it reads as a game guessing at you and guessing wrong.
Climax had made the 2007 Silent Hill prequel, which deliberately copied the first installment. Shattered Memories is the correction. It keeps the premise and rebuilds the rest, and it is the better game for it. The 7.5/10 critic aggregate across 6 outlets is fair, and maybe a touch low. This is the series entry that took the largest risk and the one later games should have studied.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
