WWE 2K17 is a wrestling game built around a simple question: can a licensed sports title keep pace with the open world, creative freedom of a sandbox. The answer, in short, is no. The game is a competent package of matches, modes, and backstage content, but it fails to justify the cost of entry for anyone who wants more than a standard season pass. It is a step forward from WWE 2K16, but a small one, and one that leaves the core gameplay unchanged.
Trailer, via IGDBcom.
The Match Engine
The core wrestling system remains largely untouched since last year’s release. Moves land with a satisfying thud, throws feel heavy, and the commentary team delivers lines with the usual mix of enthusiasm and sarcasm. What changes are mostly cosmetic: new animations, updated graphics, and a few tweaks to the controls. None of it transforms the way matches play out.
The career mode, MyCareer, is the headline feature. Players build a wrestler from scratch, choosing a name, look, and gimmick before stepping into the ring. Progression comes from matches, story missions, and backstage activities. It is a solid framework, but the pacing drags in the middle stretch. Missions often feel like busywork, and the rewards for completing them rarely justify the time spent.
Visual Style
The presentation is where WWE 2K17 makes its strongest case. Character models are detailed, arenas are bright and full of spectacle, and the crowd reactions are energetic. The game runs at a smooth frame rate across its supported platforms, which include PS3, PS4, PC, and Xbox 360. That stability is a welcome improvement over the previous year’s stuttering issues.
The commentary team, led by Jim Ross and Jerry Lawler, is a highlight. Their lines are sharp, and the banter between them adds a layer of humor that scripted dialogue struggles to match. It is a small touch, but it makes long sessions more enjoyable.
Modes and Extras
Beyond the main career, WWE 2K17 offers a range of multiplayer options. Standard matches, ladder matches, and tables matches are all present, along with a handful of new game types that add variety to online play. The mode is solid, though it lacks the depth of other sports games in the genre. There is no franchise mode, no deep stat tracking, and no way to build a full roster of custom wrestlers.
The Showcase mode returns, allowing players to recreate classic matches from WWE history. It is a fun diversion, but it is limited in scope. Only a handful of matches are available, and the replay value is low. The same goes for the Universe mode, which lets players create their own storyline. It is a nice addition, but it feels like a half-finished idea rather than a fully realized feature.
Performance and Technical Issues
The game runs well on PS4 and PC, with few technical hitches during extended play sessions. On PS3 and Xbox 360, the frame rate dips occasionally, especially during busy matches. Load times are generally quick, and the menus are easy to navigate. The audio is crisp, with clear sound effects and a strong mix of commentary.
There are some rough edges, however. Camera angles can be awkward during certain moves, and the collision detection is inconsistent. Some moves connect when they should miss, while others miss when they should connect. These issues are minor, but they add up over time and can frustrate players who want a fair contest.
The Cost Problem
The biggest problem with WWE 2K17 is the price. At full retail, the game asks for a significant investment for a product that offers little beyond what was available last year. The MyCareer mode is the only major new feature, and even that is thinly veiled marketing for the WWE brand. The game is a cash cow, and the lack of innovation shows.
There is also the issue of microtransactions. WWE 2K17 includes a season pass, which unlocks additional downloadable content, including new wrestlers and arenas. The pass is optional, but it is expensive, and it requires an online connection to access. The change is a convenience hit, and it locks players into a subscription-like model.
Comparison to Competitors
| Feature | WWE 2K17 | Other Wrestling Games |
|---|---|---|
| Career Mode | MyCareer, limited depth | Deep progression, multiple paths |
| Match Variety | Standard matches, ladder, tables | Full roster, custom rules |
| Online Play | Solid multiplayer, limited modes | Extensive online community, ranked matches |
| Presentation | Detailed models, smooth frame rate | High visual fidelity, cinematic cutscenes |
| Value | Full retail, season pass required | Lower cost, less frequent updates |
The comparison is stark. WWE 2K17 is a competent package, but it falls short of the best in the genre. Its competitors offer deeper career systems, more varied match types, and stronger online communities. WWE 2K17 is a solid game, but it is not a great one.
Final Verdict
WWE 2K17 is a modest upgrade over its predecessor. It is visually impressive, well-commentated, and reasonably priced at full retail. But the core gameplay is unchanged, the career mode is thin, and the season pass model is a step backward. For casual fans, it is a decent purchase. For serious players, it is a missed opportunity.
The game is not broken, and it is not a failure. It is simply a safe, predictable product from a company that has stopped taking risks. WWE 2K17 is a competent wrestling game that will satisfy existing fans but will not win back those who have drifted away. It is a game that coasts on reputation rather than innovation.
The score reflects that balance. WWE 2K17 is a game with moments of excellence and stretches of boredom. It is a game that shows promise but never quite delivers on it. It is a game that is worth playing for a few hours, but not worth the asking price for a full collection.
WWE 2K17 scores 6.1 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
