The Darkest Minds wants to be a rebellion, but it keeps getting lost in its own mall. Jennifer Yuh Nelson directs from Chad Hodge’s script, and the result is a movie that never quite lands its central idea — that a plague wipes out most children in America, leaving the survivors with superpowers. Amandla Stenberg plays Ruby Daly, a 16-year-old Orange telepath who escapes a government camp and joins three teens on the run. But the film’s plot keeps tripping over its own color-coded power system, which it spends half the runtime explaining and then mostly forgets.
Trailer, via 20th Century Studios.
Ruby’s Escape From The Camp
The setup is simple and grim. A mysterious infection kills nearly 90 percent of the children in the United States. Those who survive develop superpowers, which the government classifies by color: Green for increased intelligence, Blue for telekinesis, Yellow for electricity, Red for fire, and Orange for mind control. The Orange are considered so dangerous they are murdered outright. The rest are confined to camps, where the Reds are tortured and brainwashed to become a personal army for the President.
Ruby is an Orange, but she trickily places the thought of being a Green into a doctor’s head during classification. Six years later, a resistance group called the Children’s League helps her escape, and a camp worker named Cate gives Ruby a panic button that can track her location. That’s where the film should start to click. Instead it gets bogged down in a slow, talky sequence of Ruby becoming suspicious of Rob, another League member, and escaping with a mute Yellow girl named Suzume.
The Mall and The Letter
Ruby finds Liam, a Blue, and Chubs, a Green, who agree to let her join them on their way to “East River,” a supposed safe haven led by an Orange named the “Slip Kid.” In an abandoned mall, they cross paths with another group of survivors. Those others know where East River is, but they reveal only the letters “E.D.O.” as a clue — a clue that Ruby’s own power subtly influences them to give.
Chubs eventually figures out that “E.D.O.” is a radio frequency, which leads to a transmission that places East River in Lake Prince, Virginia. It’s a clever reveal, but it’s buried inside a film that doesn’t know what to do with its own revelation. The pacing here is slow, and the mall sequence, which should be tense, mostly feels like a holding pattern.
The Cast Is Strong, The Plot Is Not
Stenberg carries the film. She plays Ruby as a girl who is both clever and terrified, and her scenes of suspicion and escape land better than almost anything else in the movie. Harris Dickinson is fine as Liam, a Blue who serves mostly as Ruby’s companion. Skylan Brooks plays Chubs, a Green who is mostly a plot device. Miya Cech, as Suzume, is a quiet presence — a mute character who speaks only through action, which works better here than in most movies.
Mandy Moore plays Cate, a camp doctor fighting against the government. She’s a welcome presence, but her scenes are sparse. Patrick Gibson shows up as Clancy Gray, a bounty hunter of teens who escape from the camp. Gwendoline Christie is a presence, but her role is thin. Golden Brooks rounds out the cast as Ruby’s mother.
“The ones who changed will change everything.”
That tagline captures what the film tries to say. The survivors have changed. They are not the old children. But the film never quite figures out what that change means, beyond a few beatdowns and a final reveal that isn’t earned.
The Film’s Big Problem
The problem is the color system itself. The movie spends too much time explaining it — Green for intelligence, Blue for telekinesis, Yellow for electricity, Red for fire, Orange for mind control — and then doesn’t let any of it do real work in the story. Characters are classified, camps are labeled, and then the whole thing fades into background noise. The film is more interested in the idea of a classification system than in what that system actually means for its characters.
That’s the difference between a film with a great idea and a film with a great idea it never uses. The Darkest Minds has a great idea. But it spends too long telling you about the idea, and not enough showing you what it does to the people in it. The result is a movie that feels like a pilot episode for a show that never got picked up, full of setup and not enough payoff.
The film is also weighed down by its own ambition. It wants to be a rebellion, a tragedy, a warning, and a thriller all at once. That’s a lot to carry in 105 minutes, and the script can’t quite manage it. The mall sequence drags. The reveal of Lake Prince is fine, but it doesn’t feel like the end of a journey — it feels like the end of a beat.
The film’s biggest failure is its own premise. A plague wiping out 90 percent of children, leaving the survivors with powers, is a strong hook — but the movie never uses that hook to build real stakes. The color classifications are a way to make the story easy to follow, not a narrative engine. The film keeps returning to them as explanation rather than using them as action.
The mall sequence is the clearest example of this. A tense meeting with another group of survivors should be the film’s emotional peak. Instead it becomes a puzzle box — “E.D.O.” as a clue, “E.D.O.” as a frequency, Lake Prince as a destination — that feels like homework. The film is more interested in the process than the payoff.
The cast is strong, but the script doesn’t give them much to do. Stenberg is the exception. She makes Ruby feel alive even when the plot around her is dragging. Dickinson and Brooks play their parts well, but their roles are thin. Miya Cech is a real find as Suzume — a mute character who communicates entirely through her body, which is a challenge most movies fail.
Mandy Moore is a relief as Cate, the camp doctor. She’s a character who should be central — the insider fighting the system — but her scenes are few and scattered. Patrick Gibson and Gwendoline Christie fare worse. Their roles are thin, and the film never explains what they want or how they fit into the larger picture. Golden Brooks rounds out the family element, but her scenes are also sparse.
The film’s big reveal — that East River is in Lake Prince — should be a turning point. Instead it feels like a shrug. The movie has spent its runtime building to a destination, and when it arrives, the destination doesn’t feel earned. The film has already forgotten what made the destination worth finding.
The Darkest Minds is a film with a good idea and a good cast, but a script that can’t quite decide what it wants to do with either. Amandla Stenberg gives a solid lead performance, and the mall sequence has a few moments that work. But the color system that should drive the story is never used to its full potential, and the film never quite finds its footing. It’s a movie that tries to be a rebellion but keeps getting lost in its own mall.
A score that reflects that.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
