Prototype is a game about being a monster. That is the whole pitch, and it mostly delivers on it. The game follows Alex Mercer, a man who wakes up in a New York hospital with no memory and a strange new power. He can absorb other people, turning their bodies into raw material for new abilities. The city is under attack from a virus that turns people into grotesque creatures, and Mercer is both the key to stopping it and the prime suspect in its spread.
Trailer, via Prototype.
The Absorption System
The core mechanic is absorption. When Mercer kills an enemy, he can absorb their corpse and gain their skills. A cop might grant him a sprint boost. A soldier could give him a rocket launcher. A scientist could open up hacking tools. The system is simple to explain but deep in practice. Players spend the early hours figuring out which enemies to kill first, which powers stack best, and which routes through the city are easiest to clear once you have the right gear.
It is a genius design choice. Most action games let you pick a loadout and stick with it. Prototype lets you rebuild yourself constantly. A fight that stalls at level one might fly at level twenty, simply because you found a better gun along the way. The game rewards exploration and experimentation, since every street corner could hold a new power.
New York as a Sandbox
The game drops Mercer into a fully realized New York City. The streets are wide, the skyscrapers loom, and the crowds move through Times Square, Central Park, and the financial district. The city is a character in its own right, and it feels lived-in in a way few games manage. You can climb buildings, glide between rooftops, and tear through traffic jams with a dash ability. The city is large enough to get lost in, and that sense of scale is part of the appeal.
The presentation holds up. The lighting is strong, the crowd animations are varied, and the destruction effects are satisfying. When Mercer tears apart a tank or sends a building crumbling, the game sells the weight of it. The audio design is also strong, with a score that shifts from tense to epic depending on the situation.
The Story Problem
The problem is that the story does not match the ambition of the world around it. Mercer’s amnesia framing is thin. He remembers flashes of a life he cannot quite grasp, and the game leans on these fragments to build tension. But the plot spends too much time explaining the virus and the conspiracy behind it, and not enough time letting Mercer explore his own identity. The villain, General Augustus Voss, is a competent foil but not a memorable one. The final act rushes through a reveal that feels undercooked next to the game’s technical achievements.
The writing is serviceable, but it rarely rises above the mechanics. The voice acting is adequate, and the motion capture is occasionally stiff. None of it sinks the experience, but none of it elevates it either.
Combat and Controls
The combat is fluid and brutal. Mercer can punch, kick, and throw cars. He can grab enemies mid-air and slam them into the ground. He can call in airstrikes, summon drones, or unleash a viral burst that turns foes into infected. The game gives you dozens of moves, and it trusts you to learn which ones work best in a given fight. The controls respond well, and the game rarely feels unfair when a fight goes badly.
The difficulty curve is gentle at first, then steepens near the middle. The game throws waves of enemies at you, and the best fights require you to switch between powers mid-combat. A player who sticks with one move set will struggle against the harder encounters. The game wants you to adapt, and it rewards players who do.
Performance and Technical Issues
Prototype was a technical showcase for its time. The game pushed the PS3 and Xbox 360 hardware hard, and the results were mostly positive. The frame rate holds steady during combat, and the draw distance is impressive. The game runs at a solid 60 frames per second on the PS3, which was rare for an action title at the time.
There are issues. The game suffers from pop-in, where distant objects appear suddenly as you approach them. The draw distance can stutter, especially in crowded areas. Some textures are low-resolution, and the sky can look flat. These are minor complaints, but they are visible enough to be distracting.
On PC, the game offers a wider range of settings. The framerate can dip during heavy battles, and the game requires a decent graphics card to run smoothly. The loading times are long, which can break the flow of a mission. None of these problems ruin the experience, but they keep the game from feeling polished.
Replay Value and Length
Prototype has a main campaign that runs about twelve hours. That is a decent length, though the pacing drags in the middle. The game also includes a set of side missions and collectibles that extend the playtime. There is a challenge mode that tests your skills against tougher enemies. The game does not offer a multiplayer component, which some players will miss.
The replay value comes from the absorption system itself. You can start a new game and find different paths through the city, unlocking different powers based on which enemies you choose to absorb. The game encourages you to experiment, and that experimentation is the heart of the fun.
Where It Falls Short
Prototype is not a perfect game. Its story is thin, its villains are forgettable, and its technical issues are real. The game is also repetitive in places, particularly in the middle section where the plot slows down. The game asks you to grind through similar fights multiple times, and that repetition can wear on the player.
But the game’s strengths outweigh its weaknesses. The absorption system is a genuine innovation, and the city is a joy to explore. The combat is engaging, and the game looks good even with its flaws. Prototype is a game about becoming a god of chaos, and it mostly succeeds at that.
| Platform | Release Date | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| PS3 | 2009 | Full game, 60 fps |
| Xbox 360 | 2009 | Full game, 60 fps |
| PC | 2009 | Widescreen support, higher resolution |
| PS4 | Later release | Remastered visuals, updated controls |
Final Word
Prototype is a flawed masterpiece. It takes a simple idea — a playable monster who absorbs his victims — and builds an entire game around it. The absorption system is the best part of the game, and it carries the whole experience. The city is a joy to traverse, and the combat is satisfying. The story is weaker, and the technical issues are noticeable, but neither ruins the fun.
If you enjoy action games with a sandbox feel, Prototype is worth your time. It is a game that rewards curiosity, and it offers a unique power set that few other titles have attempted. The game is not for everyone, and its flaws are real, but its highs are high enough to recommend it.
Prototype scores 7.7 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
