Fight Club opens on a man who cannot sleep. He works an office job as an insurance claims examiner, sees a doctor about his disordered sleep, and complains that he wakes up in places he does not remember. The doctor tells him to visit a testicular cancer support group so he can see what real pain looks like. He goes. He cries. He sleeps.
That is the engine of David Fincher’s 1999 film, and it is a strange one for a movie that became shorthand for bare-knuckle mayhem. The fighting is real, but it is a symptom. The disease is a life spent shopping for furniture.
The film adapts Chuck Palahniuk’s 1996 novel, with a screenplay by Jim Uhls. It runs 139 minutes and carries the tagline “Mischief. Mayhem. Soap.” Its premiere came at the 56th Venice International Film Festival on September 10, 1999, and 20th Century Fox released it in the United States on October 15, 1999.
Trailer, via 20th Century Studios.
Edward Norton Plays a Man With No Name
Norton plays the narrator, an insomniac automobile recall specialist who is unhappy with his consumerist lifestyle. He has no name in the film, which is the point. He is a man made of catalog purchases, and he knows it.
At the support groups he meets Marla Singer, another impostor. Helena Bonham Carter plays her as an impoverished but beguiling woman, and she unnerves him precisely because she reflects him. Their confrontation produces a truce: they split the groups they attend.
Then he meets Tyler Durden on a business flight. Brad Pitt plays Tyler as a luxury soap salesman, a charismatic man who criticizes the narrator’s consumerist lifestyle and mocks him for not directly asking for a place to stay. Tyler agrees to take him in, but first asks a favor. He wants the narrator to punch him as hard as he can.
The narrator does. What follows is an agreeable exchange of painful blows, and then a movement.
A Bar, a Basement, and Robert Paulson
At Tyler’s large and decrepit house, the two start an underground fight club at a bar, framed as a way for men to reclaim control of their lives. The concept catches on. Fight clubs form in every town.
The narrator’s experiences there transform him. He grows disillusioned with his career, extorts his boss by beating himself up in the boss’s office and staging it as an assault, and uses the hush money to expand the club. New members arrive, including his cancer support group friend, Robert “Bob” Paulsen, played by Meat Loaf.
The cast around the leads is deep and specific:
- Jared Leto as Angel Face, a young member of Fight Club and Project Mayhem
- Holt McCallany as the Mechanic, a loyal member of both
- Zach Grenier as Richard Chesler, the narrator’s supervisor
- Eion Bailey as Ricky, a young recruit
- Peter Iacangelo as Lou, the bar owner where Fight Club meets
- Thom Gossom Jr. as Detective Stern, investigating Project Mayhem
Tyler saves Marla from an overdose, which leads to a sexual relationship. The narrator stays cold to her, and Tyler makes him promise not to talk to Marla about him. An eccentric gets in the way, and the whole thing spirals toward oblivion.
What Fincher Built
Fincher won the job on enthusiasm for the story, then worked the script over with Uhls, taking screenwriting notes from his cast and from others in the industry. Shooting ran in and around Los Angeles from July to December 1998. Fincher and his actors reached for Rebel Without a Cause and The Graduate as comparisons, and settled on a theme: Generation X against the value system of advertising.
That comparison is the key to the film, and it is also where the film is most honest. The narrator is not rebelling against a government or a war. He is rebelling against a sofa.
The studio did not like the film. Executives restructured Fincher’s intended marketing campaign to try to reduce anticipated losses. Fight Club failed to meet the studio’s expectations at the box office and polarized critics. It was ranked as one of the most controversial and talked-about films of the 1990s.
That history is worth holding onto, because it explains what the film is not. It is not a franchise starter. It is not a tidy parable. Studio executives disliked it enough to rework its marketing in expectation of losses, and that is a strange place from which to launch a film that would outlive most of its contemporaries.
The casting tells its own story. Producer Ross Bell met with Russell Crowe about playing Tyler Durden. Producer Art Linson, who joined the project late, met with Pitt for the same role. Linson outranked Bell, so the studio went with Pitt over Crowe. Pitt wanted a new film after Meet Joe Black flopped domestically in 1998, and the studio figured a major star would sell more tickets. It paid him $17.5 million.
For the narrator, the studio wanted a “sexier marquee name” such as Matt Damon to boost commercial prospects, and also considered Sean Penn. Fincher wanted Norton instead, based on his performance in the 1996 film The People vs. Larry Flynt. Fox offered Norton $2.5 million, but he could not accept immediately because he still owed Paramount Pictures a film. He later satisfied that obligation with his role in the 2003 film The Italian Job. In January 1998, Fox announced both leads.
The actors prepared with lessons in boxing, taekwondo, grappling, and soapmaking. Pitt voluntarily visited a dentist to have pieces of his front teeth chipped off so his character would not have perfect teeth. The pieces were restored after filming concluded.
The Cost of Being Right
Fight Club earns its reputation, but not for the reason the merchandise suggests. The film’s real subject is the gap between what the narrator owns and who he is. The support groups are the most affecting passages in the film, because they are the only place anyone tells the truth.
The film’s weakness is its own cleverness. The spiral toward oblivion is staged with more confidence than the ending can support, and the eccentric who gets in the way remains a plot turn the story never fully accounts for. But the first two acts are close to flawless.
This is a film about men who cannot sleep and cannot say what is wrong. That it became a poster on a dorm wall is an irony the film itself would have enjoyed.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
